Skip to content

Can a sports club exclude a fasting young athlete during Ramadan?

Can a sports club bar a young athlete from a training camp because they do not drink during the day during Ramadan? On 28 September 2026 the president of the French-speaking court of first instance in Brussels ruled that a Brussels gymnastics club had thereby indirectly discriminated on grounds of religion. The club had to end the exclusion, remove a clause from its internal regulations and pay the sixteen-year-old gymnast 2,000 euros.

children playing soccer

Can a sports club bar a young athlete from a training camp because they do not drink during the day during Ramadan? On 28 September 2026 the president of the French-speaking court of first instance in Brussels ruled that a Brussels gymnastics club had thereby indirectly discriminated on grounds of religion. The club had to end the exclusion, remove a clause from its internal regulations and pay the sixteen-year-old gymnast 2,000 euros.

What happened during the gymnastics camp

The boy had trained for years at a Brussels club for artistic gymnastics, and the coach confirmed at the hearing that his conduct had always been impeccable. Ramadan began on 1 March 2025. The gymnast was then 16 years and 5 months old and fasted in agreement with his parents. On 3 March, during a competition preparation camp, the coach found that three young athletes were fasting. They were allowed to finish that day with a lighter programme, but from the next day they had to choose: drink or leave. The father wrote that his son would continue fasting, to which the coach replied that he refused to let a child train who does not drink. The gymnast did not return to the camp afterwards.

Following a complaint, Unia wrote to the club. The French-speaking gymnastics federation considered the exclusion disproportionate, while the club had just introduced a new rule on 15 January 2026: every gymnast must hydrate at least every 45 minutes, on pain of suspension or exclusion. On 27 February 2026, Unia and the gymnast filed an application for a cease-and-desist order based on the Brussels Code on equality, non-discrimination and the promotion of diversity.

Why the judge found indirect discrimination

Unia argued direct discrimination. The president read the case differently. The club’s criterion was hydration, since anyone who refuses to drink is excluded, regardless of the reason. Such an apparently neutral rule nonetheless weighs more heavily on Muslims, who do not drink between sunrise and sunset during Ramadan. He therefore qualified the rule as an indirect distinction on grounds of religion, in line with the case law of the Court of Justice on the headscarf ban in the workplace.

That distinction has consequences. An indirect distinction can be justified where the rule serves a legitimate aim and the means are appropriate and necessary. It is, however, the club that must prove this.

Where the club failed the test

The judge considered the health of the athletes a legitimate aim, and the club was also entitled to watch over the safety of the minors entrusted to it. A drinking obligation was moreover an appropriate means of avoiding accidents caused by dehydration. It was on necessity, however, that the club fell short. The club had to show that exclusion was the only reasonable means, and its submissions proved only that drinking is healthy, which no one disputed.

The president pointed to obvious alternatives:

  • an adapted programme, which the club itself had already provided when the boy struggled with a knee problem for months;
  • a detailed medical certificate, if necessary from a doctor recognised by the federation;
  • a parental statement discharging the club from liability for injuries resulting from the fasting itself.

The judge also took into account that the gymnast was fully grown, had trained impeccably for seven years and could himself ask for a break. The claim that insurers do not accept such a parental statement remained unsubstantiated.

What the club must do and what the judge refused

The president ordered the immediate cessation of the discrimination. He also declared void the regulatory provision on mandatory hydration every 45 minutes, so the club must remove it. He did not order an apology, since a judge cannot compel someone to express an opinion. He likewise found publication of the decision and a penalty payment unnecessary.

For the moral damage he awarded the statutory minimum of 2,000 euros, although 6,000 euros had been claimed. The coach had no discriminatory intent and the gymnast submitted no evidence of the impact on his mental health. The judge also criticised Unia for making too little effort to reach an amicable settlement of the case. He declared Unia’s claim for compensation on its own behalf inadmissible.

What this means for clubs, parents and athletes

A club may monitor the hydration of young athletes, as long as it does not do so through a general drinking obligation on pain of exclusion. According to the ruling, a club may bar a fasting minor where a medical certificate turns out negative, and in that case it does not discriminate.

It is useful for parents to know that a minor with the capacity of discernment can bring a cease-and-desist action themselves. In this case the mother appeared at the hearing and thereby confirmed her son’s claim. Anyone who wants more than the minimum must prove the seriousness of the moral damage with evidence. Although the judge rules as in summary proceedings, the claimant does not need to prove urgency.

What to do tomorrow

If you are a director of one of the sports clubs working with young people, check your internal regulations. If they contain a general obligation to drink or eat that leads to suspension or exclusion, replace it with rules that leave room for an adapted programme, a medical certificate and a parental statement. If you receive a letter from Unia, respond with the facts and with a proposal, rather than with accusations.

If you are a parent of a young athlete who fasts, discuss this with the coach beforehand and offer a medical certificate or a written statement yourself. Also keep the messages you exchange with the club. If it concerns a gymnastics club, you can find more about our approach on the gymnastics page.

Further questions? Do not hesitate to contact us on 09/334.94.70, via the contact form or via sport@everest-law.be.

Get in touch

Tell us what you are up against.

Call us, or leave your details. You hear back within one working day.

or call +32 (0)9 334 94 70

Everest Sports Law